What Makes Renovating A Brownstone Different From Any Other Type Of NYC Property

Before overhauling your brownstone, consider the following nuances of these historic homes.

8
mins to read
Gallery Logo

What Makes Renovating A Brownstone Different From Any Other Type Of NYC Property

Brownstones offer some of the most sought after real estate in NYC. They also pose some unique challenges when renovating.

Often referred to as townhouses or row houses, Brownstones are quintessential NYC, delivering a time-tested cachet that stands out amidst contemporary building types. 

Yet, priority prestige doesn’t come without complication, as brownstones often warrant some of our most involved renovations. If you are considering renovating a brownstone in NYC, the following guide breaks down everything from brownstone renovation costs and preliminary considerations to DOB permits and external material requirements. 

Quick History of Brownstones

Ironically, today’s touted brownstones were once looked down upon. In the 1840s, when brownstone evolved from a stoop material to the fashionable facade of row houses, detractors cited the delicate nature of the soft stone as a visual detriment compared to the preferred white marble or limestone seen in more affluent areas. Over time, brownstones held up literally and figuratively, deterring detractors and evolving into gothic treasures that never fall out of favor. 

Kitchen from Brownstone renovation in Park Slope, Brooklyn. View the full renovation before and after.

Unique Challenges When Renovating NYC Brownstones 

While renovating in NYC is challenging enough, brownstone renovations pose their own unique complications. From dated craftsmanship and potential exterior work to historic ramifications and added bureaucracy, the following brownstone-centric renovation obstacles require seasoned skill and experience: 

Piecemeal Shortcuts From Previous Owners

Considering their age, finding deficient piecemeal work from previous owners is not an uncommon surprise when renovating brownstones in NYC. When they were originally built, overseeing bodies found in today’s DOB didn’t even exist, and prior occupants often hired handymen or did the work themselves. In worst-case scenarios, these shortcuts seriously compromise a building's structural integrity, and correcting them can require the help of a structural engineer.

Uneven Floors & Compromised Structural Work 

Beyond inadequate shortcuts from old owners, the pre-war status of brownstones means the processes used during the original build likely would not meet today’s standards. For example, balloon framing was popular in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. In this method, framing and wall cavities run hollow from foundation to roof with no platforms to break up structural beams on each floor. Over time, this results in insulation and moisture control problems, un-level floors, and buckling beams - all of which pose significant challenges amidst almost any level of renovation. 

Removing old balloon framing and installing platforms is extremely costly, but can be more affordable ways to remedy such issues. When renovating, insist your contractor insulate the walls and use a vapor and moisture barrier, which will combat energy loss and moisture issues, including mold. Additionally, watch for uneven floors where sistering beams might be necessary for more level structural support.

Prior to renovating, have a contractor or home inspector check electrical panels, exposed plumbing, and the quality of finish in previously renovated rooms. This will help manage expectations prior to renovation, allowing owners to know whether they’re up against minor issues or major risks.

Asbestos, Outdated Electrical And Plumbing

Unless your brownstone’s electrical and plumbing systems have been recently redone, assume they’ll have to be updated amidst any significant renovation. Brownstones characteristically used galvanized plumbing that both deposits sediments into the water and causes buildup that restricts water flow. They also often include plumbing insulated with asbestos — which must be professionally removed if they are being disturbed. Plus, electrical systems in brownstones almost always need an upgrade upon renovation, as they weren't originally equipped to handle our current average electrical consumption. 

Besides redoing electrical and plumbing, you might also need to schedule a controlled removal of asbestos from your brownstone’s walls. Testing for asbestos in the early planning stages is not only smart planning but often required in order to file architectural plans. At Gallery, we plan for any added effort required for removal or see if there are workaround cost saving measures that can leave the asbestos undisturbed. By law, if work disturbs the asbestos, mitigation is required and bringing in an asbestos remediation company for asbestos removal and air quality monitoring is likely needed. However if preliminary tests confirm asbestos won’t be disturbed during the work, we’ll avoid the area and issue altogether.

Kitchen from brownstone renovation in Brooklyn. View full renovation before and after.

Sewer Lines And Cellar Water

Since sewer clogs and backups are quite common in brownstones, inspecting sewer and waste lines before any renovation also helps ensure proper water flow. However, issues like tree roots and the fronts of some homes can still lead to clogging and overflowing lines within the building. Brownstones near high water tables, which are common in Brooklyn, are also prone to water issues in their cellars.

If your brownstone’s cellar is unfinished, signs of water issues might be obvious, such as water stains and lumps along the floor. An experienced contractor will look up the property’s permit history and advise whether or not to schedule testing before starting the renovation. For instance, if the last plumbing permit was filed in the 1980s, a pre-renovation inspection is warranted. 

Exterior Renovation Potential 

Another significant difference between brownstone renovations and other types of NYC residential renovation is the potential for exterior updates. Although timeless in theory, the exterior of these delicate, soft-stone homes often require updates alongside the interiors. From stone work on the facade and stoop improvements to balcony and gate updates, there are a variety of exterior areas apt for an upgrade. 

For an example of restoration work on brownstone exteriors, see our renovation before and after for a brownstone in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn which required a complete exterior renovation of the facade, cornices, windows, mouldings, and ironwork, including the railings leading up to the stoop and those facing the street.

Landmark Applications via Landmark Preservation Commission (LPC)

If the brownstone being renovated is designated a landmark or located on a landmark street, a landmark approval from the Landmark Preservation Commission will be needed before renovating. Additionally, if landmark status, the LPC must also approve all exterior street facing materials and design aesthetics prior to implementation, otherwise an LPC certificate of no effect is obtained. 

Exterior update with facade restoration from brownstone renovation in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn.

Brownstone Renovation Process 

While every renovation has unique variables to account for, a start to finish brownstone renovation comes down to the following stages: 

  • Architectural Drawing and DOB Filings
  • Interior Design 
  • Along with any exterior facade, gating, stoop or balcony considerations 
  • Legalities & Logistics 
  • Plumbing Inspection
  • Asbestos Test 
  • Electrical Test 
  • Building, Electrical, and Plumbing Permits from Department Of Buildings 
  • Landmark Preservation Commission (LPC) Filings 
  • Material Selection & Procurement
  • Design Renders
  • Demo & Build

For a full breakdown of each individual step in the brownstone renovation process, view our extensive blog on NYC Brownstone Renovations 101: What To Know & Where To Start.

Brownstone Renovation Expenses

Due to their dated nature and need for more delicate restoration, a full renovation of a brownstone will typically cost more per square foot than any other residential renovation in NYC. 

The average cost for a brownstone renovation in NYC is around $300 to $500 per square foot and all the way to $600 to 800 per square foot in all custom, ultra luxury renovations. Expect to pay around $900,000, to $1,600,000, to gut renovate a 3,200 square foot brownstone with mid-range to upper-mid tier finishes. For more details on commonly added costs & expenses of a brownstone gut renovation in NYC, read How Much Does It Cost To Gut Renovate A Brownstone?

Townhouse renovation in Upper East Side. View full renovation before and after.

Brownstone FAQs

How Long Is A Typical NYC Brownstone Renovation Timeline? 

Every brownstone renovation in NYC has unique needs and respective timelines are impacted by the scope, site conditions and building rules. On average, a full renovation of a three story brownstone takes 5-7 months although timelines can vary based on the specific factors, such as landmarked building status or adjustments to the floor-plan (which requires architectural plans and subsequent submission to the reviewing architect). 

Is A Full Gut Renovation Of My Brownstone Worth The Investment? 

When looking to invest in a brownstone, there are two routes to go: 

Purchase A Pre-Renovated Brownstone

The first route would be to purchase a fully-renovated brownstone that is already fit to call home. The upfront costs will be significantly higher and there’s potential some of the details won’t be personalized as you’d like - requiring some renovation anyways (potentially more than anticipated). 

Full Gut Renovation Of A Dated Brownstone

The second route is a buying a brownstone with good guts and fixer-upper appeal with intent for a full gut renovation, which means you’re paying a lower purchase price but spending to fully gut renovate the property in order to fully customize or restore every inch of the space to your liking. Traditionally this option leads to an overall lower cost compared to the first.

The latter option is surely more work but typically less costly in the long run depending on your level of luxe, but the ability to both personalize your brownstone and maximize resale value is best achieved via a true gut renovation. 

Are There Any Tax Implications From NYC Brownstone Renovations?

Property taxes for your brownstone will stay relatively flat unless square footage is being expanded or occupancy type is being changed (e.g. from 1 family or SRO to 2/3 family residence).

Are There Any Other Unexpected Costs From Renovating Brownstones?

If you’ve read this far, potential issues like asbestos, electrical, and outdated ramifications from balloon framing shouldn’t be a surprise. However, don’t forget to consider potential carrying costs and temporary housing costs. If you’re taking on a significant renovation to your brownstone and utilizing one of the floors as your temporary living space isn’t an option then you'll need to find somewhere else to stay amidst the demo and build portion of the renovation, which often leads to added costs. This could also require temporary storage for your belongings. 

Base floor from townhouse renovation in SoHo, Manhattan. View full renovation before and after.

Why Gallery For Brownstone Renovations In NYC?

We are experienced brownstone renovation contractors in New York with an end-to-end approach and expertise to drive all aspects of your brownstone renovation, from interior design and architectural planning to building board management and construction - all within one comprehensive price-point. Ready to renovate? Contact us for a consultation.

What’s a Rich Text element?

The rich text element allows you to create and format headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, images, and video all in one place instead of having to add and format them individually. Just double-click and easily create content.

Static and dynamic content editing

A rich text element can be used with static or dynamic content. For static content, just drop it into any page and begin editing. For dynamic content, add a rich text field to any collection and then connect a rich text element to that field in the settings panel. Voila!

How to customize formatting for each rich text

Headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, figures, images, and figure captions can all be styled after a class is added to the rich text element using the "When inside of" nested selector system.

let’s

Design-Build

together

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form